AARP Hearing Center
In an unprecedented move, federal health officials have updated the nation’s childhood immunization schedule, narrowing the list of universally recommended vaccines for infants and children from 17 to 11. Six vaccines, including the flu shot, are now recommended only for kids at high risk or in consultation with a physician, a practice known as shared clinical decision-making.
This change, pediatricians and public health experts warn, will not only affect the health of children but could also have an impact on adults, including older individuals who are more susceptible to severe illness from common infections.
The reason for the overhaul, Trump administration officials said, was to align the U.S. vaccine schedule with other wealthy nations, like Denmark — a country that Dr. Robert H. Hopkins Jr., medical director of the National Foundation for Infectious Diseases, points out has a much smaller population, a universal health care system and “a very different disease epidemiology” from that in the U.S.
“And I think that’s a dangerous idea, particularly doing that without any evidence or science behind making that change,” says Hopkins, who is also a professor of internal medicine and pediatrics at the University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences.
A new report from KFF, a nonpartisan health policy organization, finds that trimming the number of recommended vaccines makes the U.S. an outlier among peer nations.
Changes could fuel declining vaccination rates
While many pediatricians, insurers and professional organizations plan to stick with the previous schedule that recommended all 17 vaccines, public health experts worry that the recent changes “will lead to a false sense of mistrust in these vaccines,” says Dr. Vandana Madhavan, clinical director of the pediatric infectious disease division at Boston’s Mass General Brigham for Children.
They also introduce barriers that weren’t there before.
“Shared decision-making is not a huge issue for somebody who has a trusted health care team, because we talk about the reasons behind vaccinating as it is,” Hopkins says.
“But it’s a real challenge for people that are in health care deserts,” he adds, and for those without routine access to a provider.
The result, many health experts fear, will be a decline in vaccination rates for preventable diseases, which “will actually have an impact on the larger community,” Madhavan says.
More From AARP
Shingles Vaccine May Lower Dementia Risk
New research suggests an added benefit of the shot
Do You Need the RSV Vaccine?
The shot could help keep you out of the hospital
Surprising Signs of Infections in Older Adults
Don’t overlook these unusual symptoms as flu season approaches