Those who claim Social Security before their full retirement age already know that they won’t get the maximum benefit. Now a new report says those who claim at a less than “optimal” time are losing $111,000 per household on average.
The report underscores what many other Social Security experts say: Those who begin taking Social Security benefits earlier than their full retirement age lose significant money in the long run.
About 79 percent of eligible adults in the report's sample — some 2,000 individuals from the University of Michigan's Health and Retirement Study — claimed benefits between ages 62 and 64, though it is optimal for only about 8 percent of adults to claim that early, according to the report, “The Retirement Solution Hiding in Plain Sight: How Much Retirees Would Gain by Improving Social Security Decisions."
Changing Behaviors Toward Social Security
Americans’ attitude and behavior about when to claim Social Security benefits ought to be adjusted, says Jason J. Fichtner, coauthor of the United Income report.
The report recommends changing how Social Security claiming-age options are presented to the public. Instead of referring to age 62 as “early eligibility age,” the report says it should be called “minimum benefit age.” Age 70 should be called the “maximum benefit age."
“Changing the framing makes people think about this [decision] differently,” Fichtner says.
Your “financially optimal” claiming age means “looking at the entire picture of income you have and your wealth,” says report coauthor Jason J. Fichtner, former chief economist and former associate commissioner for retirement policy at SSA, now an associate director of the International Economics and Finance program at Johns Hopkins University School of Advanced International Studies. “Early claiming is not always the wrong decision,” he says. For example, people with a terminal illness or other costly health conditions, those who don't have significant assets in a 401(k) plan and those who have other pressing financial needs may need to claim earlier.
But for others, Fichtner advises: “Delay Social Security benefits until you need them."
Average Social Security recipients would gain 9 percent more income in retirement if they figure out the best time to claim their benefits, the report says.
"Retirees will collectively lose $3.4 trillion in potential income that they could spend during their retirement because they claimed Social Security at a financially sub-optimal time,” the report says.
The earliest age at which Americans can claim Social Security benefits is 62, but they can wait until full retirement age — 66 for those born between 1943 and 1954 — to receive higher monthly benefits. Beginning in 2020, full retirement age will increase incrementally. For those born in 1960 or later, the full retirement age is 67.
If you wait until your full retirement age, your monthly benefit will be about 30 percent more than if you claimed at 62. If you wait until you're between age 66 and 70, you'll receive about eight percent more per year or 32 percent more in total, according to SSA.
Waiting to claim can be a strategy that works. “We do encourage people to delay claiming to the extent that they can,” says Gary Koenig, vice president, financial security, AARP Public Policy Institute. “In many instances it is a good financial decision that will increase retirement security. We recognize that not everybody can delay. If you can delay, you should delay for as long as possible. If you can't make ends meet with what you have you should claim Social Security benefits.”
"Most retirees will lose wealth in their 60s and 70s if they choose to optimize Social Security, but will be wealthier in their late 70s through the rest of their lives,” the report says.