Our Friends Drink but We Don't. We're Tired of Splitting Restaurant Bills 50/50

Dining out with friends can bring people closer and make for an enjoyable experience. And many of us do, with nearly three out of 10 Americans reporting that they eat out once a week or more, a recent survey found.

However, with restaurant prices increasing — up 3.6 percent from November 2023 to November 2024 — and dining budgets tightening, some of us are choosing to forgo alcohol when we eat out, whether to save money or to reap the health benefits of drinking less.

Which raises the question: Who pays the bill when drinkers and non-drinkers dine together?

My wife and I enjoy going out to dinner with another couple, but there’s an issue. We don’t drink, but our friends do. They often order several cocktails or a bottle of wine for themselves, which adds a significant amount to the bill. We don’t think we should be responsible for splitting the check 50/50. Are my wife and I being total cheapskates? 

Total cheapskates you are not.

I’d like to start off by saying that the good etiquette move is whenever someone orders more food or alcohol, they acknowledge it and offer to get separate checks. Traditional etiquette states that the person who extends the dinner invitation foots the bill. But that's often not how we organize a dinner out with friends — we typically make plans more casually, and we often don’t discuss how the bill will be handled until the check arrives.  

I also want to reassure you that this is a common issue — and your friends might not even be aware that they’re putting you in an awkward position.

Often, people simply don’t notice that they ordered more food or drinks than their dining companions. Also, a growing number of people are abstaining from alcohol, whether as a permanent lifestyle choice or as part of a no-alcohol challenge like Dry January. (See a list of Dry January dos and don’ts below.)

Money Manners

Lizzie Post is AARP's financial etiquette columnist. She is the great-great-granddaughter of etiquette legend Emily Post. She’s also the co-president of The Emily Post Institute, co-author of Emily Post’s Etiquette: the Centennial Edition and co-host of the Awesome Etiquette podcast.

Have a question? Email us at moneymanners@aarp.org. 

Many of us are also tightening our dining budgets and cutting out drinks as a way to curb costs amid rising restaurant prices.

Given that you’ve already encountered this issue with your friends several times, I recommend addressing the topic before your next outing. This way, everyone goes into the meal knowing what to expect.

Be concise: “I know in the past we’ve split the bill, but since Allison and I aren’t drinking, we’d love to grab separate checks.” If you forget to broach the topic in advance, you can use the same line at the end of the meal.

Wanting a fair split isn’t cheap, so don’t feel embarrassed or awkward asking for separate checks. It’s a perfectly reasonable request — and if your friends balk, maybe it’s best to do at-home meals with them.