Score: 9.8 out of 10
Visit Site
Pros and cons
Pros
- Plush pillow top promotes spinal alignment
- Strong pressure relief for hips and lower back
- Comfortable for all sleeping positions
Cons
- Movement may wake up lighter sleepers
Features
- Materials: Hybrid
- Firmness: Luxury firm
- Trial period: 120 nights
- Warranty: Limited lifetime
Key takeaways from our testing
Soft upper layers help with spinal alignment. Although it’s classified as a luxury firm mattress, the Nolah Evolution has a thick, plush pillow top that provides a balance of softness and support. Dana said the lofted top felt soft and cushioned, while the deeper layers provided structure. “Even though there’s a lot of foam, it’s not too soft. I still felt lifted and supported,” she said. Karin agreed: “My back feels wonderful. There’s great pressure relief and spinal alignment. I feel cradled by the soft cover and the good support underneath.”
Tester Karin said the Nolah Evolution Luxury Firm’s plush, quilted cover felt soft yet supportive.
AARP Smart Picks
Strong pressure relief in all positions. Karin reported excellent pressure relief in all positions, which helped keep her spine aligned. She didn’t experience pressure buildup in her hips or lower back, and she found stomach sleeping comfortable as well. However, softer mattresses can sag over time for some body types, which may pull the hips out of alignment and worsen sciatic pain. If you prefer a firmer feel, the DreamCloud Classic Hybrid may be a better option.
Noticeable motion transfer. Like many hybrid mattresses, the Nolah Evolution prioritizes bounce over motion isolation. During our ripple test, Karin rated the mattress a 3.5 out of 5 for isolating movement. “The liquid moved more when I switched positions, swaying side to side. I’ve seen better,” she said. If your sleep is easily disrupted, a mattress with stronger motion isolation, such as the Helix Dusk Luxe, may be a better fit.
How we tested the best mattresses for sciatica
We started our process by researching the market. What mattresses are popular and why? Who has the best customer reviews — and are the reviews legitimate? After talking with medical experts, we narrowed our list from 50 mattresses to the more than 30 we tested in our lab.
To identify their strengths and weaknesses, we used controlled tests to assess performance metrics like edge support, bounce and temperature regulation. Then we recruited more than 15 testers ages 50 and older to give us their unbiased feedback.
These testers answered questions like: Did the mattresses provide good pressure relief on your lower back and hips? (Pressure buildup in those areas is common for people with sciatica) Does the mattress support your lower back in all positions? Is your spine aligned with your hips? Beds that excelled in our tests made our list of the best mattresses for sciatica. For more details, see our mattress testing methodology.
How to choose the best mattress for sciatica for you
Nearly 60 percent of our survey respondents said they wanted a new mattress because their current one felt uncomfortable or because they hoped a new bed would help relieve their sciatic pain. However, before buying a new mattress for sciatica, talk with your health care provider. A supportive mattress can help reduce discomfort, but it’s not guaranteed to resolve sciatic pain on its own.
Based on insights from medical experts and our survey and test results, here’s what to consider when shopping for a mattress if you have sciatica.
Source of sciatic pain
Sciatica can stem from several underlying conditions, including herniated discs, arthritis and bone spurs. Understanding what causes your symptoms can help you choose a mattress with the right type of support. “These sciatica triggers are precisely why mattress choice can be so critical,” says Morse. “Your mattress can either alleviate or worsen nerve irritation.”
If your sciatica is caused by a herniated disc, Morse says consistent spinal support is especially important. “The mattress needs to keep the vertebrae aligned and prevent compression or twisting of the spine,” she says.
A mattress that supports the natural curve of the spine and keeps it in a neutral position can reduce stress on the sciatic nerve and help ease pain overnight.
Mattress type
There are four main mattress types: innerspring, memory foam, hybrid and latex. While no single type is proven best for sciatica, each offers characteristics that may help, depending on your symptoms and mobility needs.
- Innerspring. Innerspring mattresses have a base layer of metal coils, and they tend to be bouncy and supportive. Some may place too much pressure on sensitive nerves, but models with thick foam toppers, like the Saatva Classic, can offer better cushioning while still making movement easier.
- Memory foam. Memory foam mattresses tend to be forgiving and relieve pressure. They vary widely in firmness, depending on their foam density. High-density foams can support spinal alignment while cushioning pressure points, which may help reduce irritation of the sciatic nerve.
- Hybrid. Hybrid mattresses, which mix foam layers with innerspring coils, “can work well for people with sciatica,” says Anne Marie Morse, a neurologist and sleep medicine doctor in Pennsylvania. That’s because the combination of foam’s contouring pressure relief and the responsive support of coils helps cushion areas sensitive to sciatic pain, like the lower back. However, construction varies widely, meaning comfort, firmness and temperature regulation can differ from model to model. Still, they often offer a great balance of pressure relief and support, and they’re one of the most popular types of mattresses on the market. Five out of the six beds on this list are hybrids.
- Latex. While we didn’t test a latex mattress for this review, latex is naturally bouncy and breathable. It can provide strong pressure relief and durability, says Morse.
Firmness
Most mattress brands measure firmness on a scale from 1 to 10, with 10 being the firmest. Between 5 to 6.5 out of 10 (medium to medium firm) is the common firmness for most models.
A supportive hybrid mattress may help ease sciatic pain
“The pain is not completely gone, but it's definitely made a difference. Switching to a firmer hybrid has helped.” – Focus group participant
FAQs
What is the best type of mattress for sciatica?
The best mattresses for sciatica balance comfort, cushioning and support. Hybrid mattresses often work well for people with sciatic pain because they combine pressure-relieving foam with supportive innerspring coils. Memory foam mattresses can provide deep contouring, but if they lack a supportive base, heavier areas like the hips may sink too far, which could pull the spine out of alignment and irritate the sciatic nerve.
What is the best level of mattress firmness for sciatica?
Medium-firm mattresses are often a good choice for people with sciatica. Many support spinal alignment while still allowing the hips and shoulders to sink slightly. This balance helps reduce pressure points that could worsen sciatic pain.
Can a mattress topper help relieve sciatica?
A mattress topper may help ease sciatic discomfort by adding cushioning and improving pressure relief. Morse says a topper can help conform to the body and promote spinal alignment, especially if a mattress feels too firm. Look for a topper that’s medium-soft to medium in firmness so you don’t lose your mattress’s underlying support.
Can your mattress make sciatic pain worse?
Yes, a mattress that’s too soft or sagging can pull the spine out of alignment, compressing the sciatic nerve and exacerbating sciatic pain. However, a mattress that’s too firm could prevent the shoulders and hips from sinking, increasing nerve pressure and irritation. Hansraj says finding the right balance of support and cushioning is key to avoiding overnight flare-ups.
FAQs
What is the best type of mattress for sciatica?
The best mattresses for sciatica balance comfort, cushioning and support. Hybrid mattresses often work well for people with sciatic pain because they combine pressure-relieving foam with supportive innerspring coils. Memory foam mattresses can provide deep contouring, but if they lack a supportive base, heavier areas like the hips may sink too far, which could pull the spine out of alignment and irritate the sciatic nerve.
What is the best level of mattress firmness for sciatica?
Medium-firm mattresses are often a good choice for people with sciatica. Many support spinal alignment while still allowing the hips and shoulders to sink slightly. This balance helps reduce pressure points that could worsen sciatic pain.
Can a mattress topper help relieve sciatica?
A mattress topper may help ease sciatic discomfort by adding cushioning and improving pressure relief. Morse says a topper can help conform to the body and promote spinal alignment, especially if a mattress feels too firm. Look for a topper that’s medium-soft to medium in firmness so you don’t lose your mattress’s underlying support.
Can your mattress make sciatic pain worse?
Yes, a mattress that’s too soft or sagging can pull the spine out of alignment, compressing the sciatic nerve and exacerbating sciatic pain. However, a mattress that’s too firm could prevent the shoulders and hips from sinking, increasing nerve pressure and irritation. Hansraj says finding the right balance of support and cushioning is key to avoiding overnight flare-ups.
A firm mattress may help relieve some types of back pain, but that’s not always ideal for sciatica, says Morse. She generally recommends a medium-firm firmness, which allows the hips and shoulders to sink slightly while keeping the spine aligned. Research backs this up.
Firmness can feel different, though, depending on your body weight and shape. Lighter-weight sleepers may prefer softer mattresses with more cushioning, such as the Nolah Evolution, while higher-weight sleepers may want firmer support, like the DreamCloud Classic Hybrid.
Look for a mattress that keeps your spine aligned in its natural curve while supporting the hips and lower back. “Too firm, and the shoulders and pelvis can’t sink enough,” which can increase hip pain and irritate the sciatic nerve, says Kenneth Hansraj, a spinal and orthopedic surgeon at Premier Medical Group in Poughkeepsie, New York.
Maintaining neutral spinal alignment helps reduce irritation of the sciatic nerve by limiting unnecessary pressure and micro-movements, Hansraj adds.
Pressure relief for hips and lower back
Every mattress in our review scored a 3.8 out of 5 or higher for pressure relief. We prioritized beds that cushioned common areas of sciatic pain, such as the hips and lower back.
“The ideal mattress provides a balance of strong support and contouring pressure relief,” says Morse. Mattresses that are too firm can aggravate inflamed nerves, while overly soft mattresses may fail to support the spine. Hybrid and memory foam mattresses often strike the right balance.
Responsiveness
If sciatic pain makes it difficult for you to change positions or get out of bed, look for a “responsive” mattress — one that responds to your movements and doesn’t “suck” your body in. Memory foam mattresses tend to be less responsive, while hybrid and latex mattresses usually make movement easier.
Hybrid mattresses combine pressure-relieving foam with responsive coils. “That combination cushions pressure points while providing the support needed to stay aligned,” says Morse.
The Helix Dusk Luxe, Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid and DreamCloud Classic Hybrid all earned high scores for responsiveness in our testing.
Trial period
A generous sleep trial gives you more time to determine whether a mattress helps ease your sciatica symptoms. Some brands, including Saatva, DreamCloud and Nectar, offer a free 365-night trial, while others offer 120-night or shorter trials.
How much do the best mattresses for sciatica cost?
The mattresses on our list cost between about $1,300 and $2,400 for a queen, depending on the brand and model.
The most affordable option is the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid at $1,332. The Helix Dusk Luxe is the most expensive model at $2,399, but it earns high marks across our tests for bounce, edge support and temperature regulation.
Questions or feedback? Email us at AARPSmartPicks@aarp.org.
You Might Also Like
What’s the Best Mattress for Side Sleepers?
These are the best mattresses for side sleeping — the most common sleeping position.
Top Mattresses for Arthritis Based on Testing
These six beds may help ease joint pressure for people with arthritis
Best Mattresses for Back Pain of 2026
See how we test the best beds for back pain and shop our top picks