Skip to content

Grief Hurts the Heart

Study shows its impact on the bereaved

In the weeks after losing a spouse or child, the bereaved are much more likely to experience rapid heartbeats and other potentially dangerous changes in heart rhythm, according to a study presented Sunday at an American Heart Association conference in Chicago.

The findings offer a glimpse into the physiology underlying an ancient folk belief: that a person can perish of a "broken heart."

In fact, research over the last half-century has established a firm link between bereavement and an increased risk of dying from any cause, and from cardiovascular events like a heart attack, sudden cardiac arrest and stroke in particular.

One Scottish study published in 2007 found that, even after controlling for other risk factors, loss of a spouse increased a person's chances of dying by nearly 20 percent. An earlier study suggested that, during the first day of bereavement, a person's risk of nonfatal heart attack is increased as much as 14-fold.

In the latest study, led by Thomas Buckley, of the University of Sydney Nursing School, 78 people who had lost a spouse or child within the previous two weeks were tested using round-the-clock heart monitors, questionnaires and other tools, then reexamined six months later.

Initially, those who were suffering a loss had higher average heart rates, more episodes of rapid heartbeat and reductions in the normal variation in heart rate — as well as sharply increased anxiety and depression — compared with people in the control group. But at six months, those in the bereaved group showed the same heart activity as those in the control group; their anxiety and depression also had diminished.

"This is interesting as a study of mechanisms," says Rachel Lampert, M.D., a cardiologist at the Yale School of Medicine whose own research has documented similar heart-rhythm changes after the 9/11 terrorist attack in people who happened to be wearing heart monitors. Normally, the heart rate slows very slightly as a person breathes in. Reductions in this natural variability, as well as overall hikes in heart rate, may signal that the body's fight-or-flight response is in overdrive, says Lampert. This disturbance of the nervous system might, in turn, trigger potentially fatal heart attacks or arrhythmias in susceptible people.

The changes are not necessarily a sign of underlying heart disease, says Buckley, the Sydney study's lead author. "People have great capacity to absorb changes in heart rate or heart-rate variability." On the other hand, he says, in those with underlying risk even short episodes of anger or other distressing feelings have been implicated in cardiac events. The bereavement-related changes seem to last for days, perhaps weeks or even months. "That's quite a long hazard period," says Buckley.

Work published in 2009 by Buckley and colleagues also showed, among the newly bereaved versus controls, higher anger ratings, reduced sleep and appetite, and increases in morning levels of the stress hormone cortisol.

Buckley says evidence does not suggest any benefit from early psychological intervention in grieving, which after all is a normal process. But he does say more research should look at therapies aimed specifically at reducing heart rate, and that physicians should be aware of heart risks in patients coping with the loss of a loved one.

Lampert agrees: "This points out the need to be paying careful attention to symptoms like chest pain and shortness of breath" in such patients, she says.

Katharine Greider lives in New York and writes about health and medicine.