AARP Hearing Center
Key takeaways
- A stolen wallet led to years of identity fraud for Jessica Roy, even after she canceled the cards, reported the theft, and obtained a new driver’s license.
- Identity theft can spread beyond financial accounts, affecting credit, benefits, taxes, passwords, and other parts of a victim’s life.
- Experts recommend documenting every step, reporting the crime, freezing credit, monitoring accounts, and seeking support during recovery.
Jessica Roy’s years-long identity fraud nightmare began with a stolen wallet. The theft occurred in a San Francisco bar in 2018, and Roy — then a reporter with the Los Angeles Times, now a financial columnist with the San Francisco Chronicle — took quick action. She disputed charges the next morning (the thieves had used her debit card), canceled her debit and credit cards, and reported her stolen wallet to local police. Soon after, she obtained a new driver’s license and updated her bill payments through auto-pay.
She thought the matter was closed. Then Bank of America and Wells Fargo mailed her approval notices for accounts she hadn’t opened. The thieves had applied for accounts with Macy’s, PayPal, and Walmart, she learned from a site where she tracked her credit score. She received email notifications that her passwords had been changed.
Roy froze her credit with the three major credit bureaus and filed a federal ID theft complaint. But the problem worsened. Although Roy had reported her driver’s license stolen, Bank of America and Wells Fargo issued checkbooks for accounts the criminals had opened. Soon, she received letters about bad checks, including one for nearly $14,000 at Big Lots. The thieves used her driver’s license to rent a Tesla, which was later reported stolen.
The last incident occurred in 2021, roughly three years after the wallet theft. But Roy knows she could be victimized again. “Eva Velasquez [CEO of the nonprofit Identity Theft Resource Center (ITRC)] told me that getting your identity stolen is like having a chronic illness,” Roy says. “You can have it under control for a long time, but a flare-up could always happen.”
If identity fraud is like a chronic illness, the crimes are reaching an epidemic stage. Identity fraud cost Americans an estimated $27.3 billion in 2025, affecting roughly 18 million victims, according to a Javelin Strategy & Research report.
“My advice to someone going through identity theft is that it is possible to fight it and win,” says Roy, who also recounted her experience in the Los Angeles Times. “It just takes way, way, way more effort than it should, and no one is invested in helping you or doing anything to prevent this from happening to anyone else.” (Check out AARP’s tips for identity theft prevention.)
More on What to Do After a Scam
What to Do if Your Wallet Is Lost or Stolen
7 steps to prevent identity theft and money loss — plus how to replace what’s missing