AARP Hearing Center
I Became a Dad at 40. Here’s What They Don’t Tell You About Raising a Teen in Your 50s
Everyone said fatherhood would be harder if I waited. They were right, but not in the ways that mattered
Late-in-life fatherhood has its surprises. One of them is discovering your teenager now has better stories than you do.
Peter Arkle
When my son, Charlie, was born, just seconds after he arrived squinting and furious at the indignity of it all, the first thing I said to him was, “I promise Daddy doesn’t cry like this all the time.”
The nurses laughed. I felt guilty right away, because I was lying to my son within his first minute of life. I do cry like that. Not constantly, but with enough regularity that anyone close to me should be issued a poncho. I was crying because he was beautiful and because my wife, Kelly, had just performed a biological miracle while I stood nearby in a paper gown.
More Ways to Benefit
- Related Benefit 1
- Related Benefit 2
- Related Benefit 3
- Related Benefit 4
- Related Benefit 5
I was also crying because this tiny person was now, apparently, our responsibility.
This was alarming, because my entire body of work as a human being up to that point suggested I shouldn’t be placed in charge of anything more complicated than a sandwich. I was 40 years old. I’d spent the better part of two decades perfecting the art of not being responsible for anyone but myself. I had opinions about foreign films. My wardrobe was mostly punk rock tour shirts. I’d once considered a Sunday successful because I bought batteries and remembered where I put them. Now I was somebody’s father.
How we got here (eventually)
Kelly and I spent our 30s as a couple that avoided parenthood for the same reason we recycled: Given the condition of the planet, it seemed like the least selfish thing we could do. Also, we liked sleeping in.
Then, somewhere around 37, that certainty started to wobble. We found ourselves staring at other people’s children with an intensity that was hard to explain and would’ve been difficult to defend in court. Not desperate, but more in the way you suddenly take note of a restaurant you’ve walked past for years.
Long before his midnight house shows, Charlie was already working through some very serious couch-based guitar theory.
Courtesy Eric Spitznagel
We were sitting on a crosstown bus one afternoon, probably arguing about whether Wong Kar-wai’s best work was behind him, when we both went quiet. I looked over and realized we were both staring at the same thing: a 4-year-old girl with blond curls and a smile that could melt butter. The way she kicked her legs back and forth, too short to reach the floor. The way she clutched a beaten-up stuffed rabbit like it was the most important thing in the world. The way she looked up at her mother and said something that made them both laugh.
Kelly turned to me, and I turned to her, and we had one of those unspoken conversations that only happen after you’ve been together long enough to communicate in facial expressions. We were thinking the same thing: What if we got one of those?
We started trying at 38. It did not go smoothly.
Three rounds of IVF. A fertility clinic with a lobby floor inexplicably tiled in cheerful cartoon sperm. A doctor who reviewed our chart, looked up over his glasses and muttered, “I wish you were younger.” It was like going to a tailor and having him look you up and down and sigh, “I wish you were shorter.” This is what we’re working with, buddy. Make it happen.
We ran out of money. We ran out of patience. We ran out of goodwill at dinner parties, where well-meaning friends offered increasingly specific advice about conception.
After three failed rounds, we quit. We went to Florida for a long weekend and made the decision to stop making decisions about any of this and simply enjoy being two people who’d chosen each other. It turns out that’s a fairly powerful thing to remember after you’ve spent several years treating your marriage like a science experiment.
Nine months later, we had Charlie.
Our family, approximately one minute after being promoted beyond our qualifications.
Courtesy Eric Spitznagel
A growing trend of late-in-life parenthood
We weren’t alone in coming to parenthood late. The birth rate for women ages 40 to 44 has risen almost continuously since 1985, and women 40 and older had 96,809 more births in 2023 than in 1990, a 193 percent increase. Halle Berry was 47 when she had her son, Maceo. Salma Hayek was 41 when she had her daughter, Valentina. Susan Sarandon had her son Jack at 42 and her son Miles at 45. None of them seemed like cautionary tales. The window, it turns out, is considerably larger than advertised, especially for those with the resources to pursue fertility treatments and the support systems to make it work.
Later that first night, when the nurses had left and Kelly was asleep, I leaned over Charlie’s bassinet and whispered, “Daddy doesn’t have a clue what he’s doing.” And I swear, he looked up at me with an expression that said, “Well then, get your sh-t together, old man.”
For the first years of his life, I felt like someone who’d wandered into the cockpit during turbulence and was now being asked to land the plane. Every parenting decision felt impossible. Should he eat this? Should he wear that? Was the rash normal? Was the gurgle normal? Was the silence normal? Was it bad that I had just Googled “baby sneezing existential significance”?
I’d spent my 30s as a childless control freak with ulcer-inducing anxiety about my career, my relationships and the perfectly controlled pop culture museum exhibit I called home. Then this small, beautiful, catastrophically sticky person arrived and began dismantling the exhibit with both hands and part of his face.
There’s a version of the older-father story where 40 is too late. It’s the one where you spend your kid’s childhood doing grim actuarial math, worrying you won’t be around long enough, and discovering that getting up from the floor now requires both strategy and a small prayer. That version is real. I can injure myself while sleeping. I once made a noise getting out of a chair that caused the dog to leave the room.
But it’s only one version of the story. When you become a father at 40, you’ve accumulated enough loss and joy and genuine understanding of how fast everything moves to know, from the first day, how lucky you are to be there for any of it. You can’t sleepwalk through it. I’d spent decades thinking I had life more or less figured out, and then a tiny person arrived and revealed, with considerable efficiency, that I understood almost nothing.
A baby will do that. A baby looks at your priorities, crawls over to them and puts them in his mouth. But sometimes a big, sloppy, anarchic mess is exactly what’s needed to make you loosen your white-knuckled grip on everything.
One morning, when Charlie was around 5, I walked down to our basement and found him completely naked, wearing only fuzzy wolf earmuffs, playing his synthesizer. He told me he’d written a new song called “Iznunna.” I asked what an Iznunna was.
“Iznunna your biz-ness,” he said, and then improvised something that was half Beck and half Screamin’ Jay Hawkins. It remains, to this day, the most brilliant thing I’ve ever heard in my life.
This is the thing nobody puts in the brochure about raising kids. You don’t just get a child. You get a second pass at the world. You get to hear an old song with new ears. You get to see your own stale assumptions dragged into the yard and hosed down by somebody who still believes every problem can be improved by adding a robot that poops slime.
This is what practice looks like when your teenager has a band, a porch and no interest in being reasonable about volume.
Courtesy Eric Spitznagel
They grow up so fast …
Charlie is 15 now. Last weekend, he spent a Friday loose in Chicago with his band, a group called Clam, who played at a house show on the North Side. They rehearsed at the drummer’s house, went thrift shopping for show outfits, drove to Wisconsin to pick up an amp, played a surprise set in a Skokie forest preserve, ate a hundred wings at an Uptown spot, and finally ended up at their gig around midnight.
Kelly and I tracked all of this in real time through location sharing and sporadic texts, which is the contemporary version of pressing your nose against the glass. In my day, parents simply had no idea where you were. This wasn’t freedom so much as poor municipal intelligence. If your parents wanted to know your location in 1986, they had to call another landline and hope somebody’s weird older brother answered.
Charlie came home around 2 a.m., still sweaty, talking at a volume that suggested he’d spent six hours surrounded by loud guitars and people who had absolutely nowhere to be. He was practically levitating. I was sitting there trying to pretend that being awake at 2 a.m. didn’t feel like something that could actually kill me.
Parenting a teenager who’s living their best life can be quietly heartbreaking, because they need you a little less every week, and you used to be the whole universe. But watching him describe his day, the band, the road trips, the forest preserve, the wings, the midnight set, I felt something shift. Not grief, exactly. More like watching a movie you love reach the part where the main character stops needing to be rescued. I remain, 16 years in, deliriously proud and frequently teary-eyed that I had anything to do with making him.
We were better at this because we were older. More patient. More grateful. More aware, from the very first moment, of exactly what we’d been handed.
Everyone who told us we were too late was working from a perfectly reasonable set of assumptions. They just didn’t account for what happens when two people who spent decades learning how to pay attention are finally given something genuinely worth watching.
AARP Membership
Join AARP for only $15 per year with automatic renewal. Get instant access to members-only products and hundreds of benefits, a free second membership, and a subscription to AARP The Magazine.
You Might Also Like