Javascript is not enabled.

Javascript must be enabled to use this site. Please enable Javascript in your browser and try again.

Skip to content
Content starts here
CLOSE ×
Search
CLOSE ×
Search
Leaving AARP.org Website

You are now leaving AARP.org and going to a website that is not operated by AARP. A different privacy policy and terms of service will apply.

A New, Edgier Style of Cozy Mystery Goes Beyond Kittens and Tea Cups

Readers are embracing witty and gore-free detective stories, now with a more modern vibe


cozy mystery books
A new style of cozy mystery has gone mainstream.
(Left to right) Penguin Random House; Minotaur Books; Penguin Random House

Murder mysteries are perennial staples of best-seller lists, but some readers eager for a puzzling plot aren’t fans of their often dark, violent storylines. Enter cozy mysteries, a sunnier alternative to gritty police-detective fiction; you’ll still find a killing at their centers, but bloody crime scenes and spine-tingling suspense are replaced by large helpings of warmth and humor.

Never heard of them? You may nonetheless be familiar with their vibe if you’ve read Agatha Christie’s Miss Marple books or watched the television versions — or seen the show Murder She Wrote. And “the Hulu series Only Murders in the Building is a cozy,” says Mandy Chahal, marketing manager for Poisoned Pen Press, a division of Sourcebooks that publishes a wide range of cozies, including Amanda Flower’s hugely popular Amish-themed mysteries.

The key markers of a cozy include a small-town setting, an amateur sleuth, likable characters, murder in the background (no gory descriptions), a possible love interest (but no sex scenes), loads of red herrings and a sense of humor — often reflected in the books’ pun-happy titles (think Game of Scones and Up to No Gouda).  

Food themes are popular, as in the new cheese shop series Korina Moss has kicked off with Cheddar Off Dead. And their illustrated covers tend to feature homey scenes of fireplaces, cats, comfy-looking reading chairs, baked goods and teacups.    

Now a new style of mild-mannered murder mystery is growing in popularity. It riffs on the cozy genre but has a bit more edge — closer to a Janet Evanovich novel than Murder She Wrote — and is printed with more modern-looking covers as higher-quality trade paperbacks rather than mass-market offerings. Among recent hits are Elle Cosimano’s series featuring Finlay Donovan, a single mom who has been mistaken for a hit woman, and Richard Osman’s Thursday Murder Club series, focusing on four charming septuagenarian sleuths, residents in a luxury retirement village in England who meet once a week to contemplate cold murder cases (read an excerpt from the first book, The Thursday Murder Club). A Netflix adaptation starring Helen Mirren (79), Pierce Brosnan (71), and Ben Kingsley (81) is due out later this year (it’s billed as “a whodunnit with teeth — false ones, of course”).

Ready to give the new generation of cozy mysteries a try? Consider one of these new and upcoming releases.    

cozy mystery books
Penguin Random House

Kills Well With Others by Deanna Raybourn

Raybourn’s witty follow-up to her huge bestseller Killers of a Certain Age again features four women in their 60s — Billie, Helen, Mary Alice and Natali — who work as elite assassins for an organization known as the Museum. Antsy after their year off from killing, they’re ready to take on a tough case involving an Eastern European gangster seeking to kill the Museum assassins who’ve obstructed his evil plans. The fantastic foursome sets out on an international adventure to find their trigger-happy nemesis.

cozy mystery books
Penguin Random House

Vera Wong’s Guide to Snooping (on a Dead Man) by Jesse Q. Sutanto

The lovable but exasperating tea shop owner Vera Wong is getting bored: She needs a murder to solve, so she begins a search for the killer of a young high-rolling TikTok influencer named Xander by seeking out everyone connected to him and plying them with questions and home cooking. Like its predecessor, Vera Wong’s Unsolicited Advice for Murderers (2023), it’s a fun mystery with heart.

cozy mystery books
Penguin Random House

One Death at a Time by Abbi Waxman (April 15)

“The dead man was not a good swimmer” is how this fun, clever tale begins. It’s where we meet Julia, a grumpy ex-actress wanted for murder after a dead body is found in her swimming pool, a rifle nearby. She teams up with her sobriety sponsor to search for the real killer. Her sobriety sponsor, Natasha (they met at an AA meeting), wants to keep her both on the wagon and out of jail — where she’s already been once -- so the two set out to unravel the mystery in a madcap adventure in and around Los Angeles. One note: Don’t read it if you’re offended by curses; Julia’s got quite a mouth on her! Some may not consider it a cozy, but it’s got murder and the feel-good vibes noted above, so why not? Waxman is also the author of other light-hearted novels that aren’t mysteries, including The Bookish Life of Nina Hill.

cozy mystery books
Penguin Random House

Vice and Virtue by Libby Klein (April 29)

Blue-haired senior detectives are nothing new in this genre, but in her latest mystery, author Libby Klein introduces a blue-haired protagonist of a different type: Her hair is blue blue. Layla Virtue is a thirtysomething ex-cop who’s in recovery and aiming to reinvent herself as a rock star. She’s making her way up from the bottom and finds herself performing at an eight-year-old’s birthday party, where she meets Chuckles the Clown — who quickly ends up poisoned. To protect herself from suspicion and clear her name, she decides to search for answers, which leads Layla into an atmosphere of suburban snobbery and trust funds that’s worlds away from the trailer park she calls home. Expect a dose of sharp-edged sarcasm that feels like a bracing spritz of lemon on a traditionally sweet genre.

cozy mystery books
Penguin Random House

The Busybody Book Club by Freya Sampson (May 27)

Fans of Richard Osman’s The Thursday Murder Club will love this new novel from Sampson, her fourth, which follows a similarly enthusiastic crew of amateur British detectives. Protagonist Nova Davies moves from London to a seaside village in Cornwall, where she starts a book club at the community center. The quintet of literary lovers squabbles over little things (which books to read, which biscuits to bring as snacks). The disagreements turn dark, however, when money (about $7,700 in American dollars) goes missing from the center — and darker still when one of their squad disappears after a corpse is found at his house. The remaining members band together to find the money and their missing friend, each approaching the mystery from the point of view of the genres they love, including romance, sci-fi, and Agatha Christie classics. 

Also of note:

The Summer Guests by Tess Gerritson: The second book in Gerritsen’s Martini Club Series (after The Spy Coast) again features her four martini-sipping ex-CIA operatives, now searching for a missing teenager.

This Is Not a Game by Kelly Mullen (April 8): The debut mystery features a widow, Mimi, living on idyllic Mackinac Island in Michigan when a wealthy socialite is murdered. She and her estranged granddaughter, Addie, team up to find the killer.

Detective Aunty by Uzma Jalaluddin (May 6): How about another grandma/granddaughter caper? Widow Kausar Khan’s adult daughter is accused of murder, she goes in search of the actual killer with help from her granddaughter.

Savvy Summers and the Sweet Potato Crimes by Sandra Jackson-Opoku (July 29): This series debut features a Chicago soul-food restaurant proprietor who becomes an amateur sleuth after a customer dies in her café.

Unlock Access to AARP Members Edition

Join AARP to Continue

Already a Member?