Alert
Close

Take AARP’s Smart Driver course and you could save money on your car insurance. Learn more

Highlights

Open
AARP Real Possibilities

 

FREE FUN!

AARP Games - Play Now!

Contests and
Sweeps

Safe Driving in 2014 Sweepstakes

Learn how AARP Driver Safety can help you stay safe—and enter for a chance to win $1,000. See official rules. 

AARP Auto Buying Program

MOST POPULAR

Viewed

Medicare Becomes Political Hot Potato

A surprise election result turns into a partisan tug-of-war rattling the 2012 campaign

Erie County Clerk Kathleen C. Hochul speaks at the UAW Hall in Williamsville, N.Y. Tuesday May 24, 2011 after winning the race in the 26th Congressional District.

May 24, 2011: New York Democrat Kathleen Hochul declares victory in the 26th district's special Congressional election. — — Harry Scull Jr./The Buffalo News/AP

The biggest issue so far for the 2012 political campaign? Medicare.

All it took was one special election in upstate New York, where a combustible proposal from Rep. Paul Ryan, R-Wis., to remake the Medicare system into a voucher program reshaped the political landscape in the traditionally conservative New York district outside of Buffalo.

See also: Senate rejects GOP's Medicare proposal.

Democrat Kathy Hochul's victory in a historically Republican district, which had never elected a Democrat, was fueled in large measure by older voters energized by the Medicare proposal. Preelection polls showed likely voters over 55 favored Hochul, a dramatic shift from the 2008 election in which John McCain swamped Barack Obama.

While Democrats are happy to keep the political spotlight on the Medicare debate, Republicans were shaken, and some began having second thoughts. Most Republican lawmakers, starting with House Speaker John Boehner of Ohio, are sticking with Ryan's prescription for Medicare, which would change it from a government-sponsored health insurance plan to a government subsidized purchase plan for private insurance. House Republicans voted overwhelmingly for the Ryan budget plan, including Medicare.

But fissures in the party are beginning to show.

A test vote in the Democrat-controlled Senate on the Ryan plan didn't pass, and there were five GOP defectors. Each showed a specific reason that could make Republicans vulnerable in the 2012 election. (All Democrats voted against it.) The GOP five were Sens. Scott Brown (Mass.), Susan Collins (Maine), Olympia Snowe (Maine), Lisa Murkowski (Alaska) and Rand Paul (Ky.).

Brown is facing a probable Democratic challenge next year in liberal-leaning Massachusetts. Snowe is likely to pick up a Tea Party challenger in the Republican primary, but appeared to be looking toward the general election in the more moderate state of Maine, as was Collins, who is not up next year but often burnishes her middle-of-the-road credentials. Murkowski owes her election to independents in Alaska, and her votes lately have showed it. Only Paul was an outlier, saying he voted "no" because the Ryan budget didn't make a large enough dent in the $14.3 trillion federal debt.

Congressional Democrats are delighted to see the focus on Medicare. Having lost control of the House last year, their majority in the Senate is tenuous, with 23 of the 33 Senate seats now held by Democrats at stake in 2012.

Impact on presidential politics

Presidential candidates are wobbly too. Former Minnesota Gov. Tim Pawlenty, pressed by reporters to support or criticize the Ryan plan, hedged only slightly in supporting it. He said he would sign it "if I can't have my own plan as president."

Former Utah Gov. Jon Huntsman also says he would have voted for the Ryan budget, including the Medicare provision. But former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney, whose own health care plan for his state resembled President Obama's Affordable Care Act, said Ryan's plan is "not identical" to what he will propose. However, Romney praised Ryan's effort as going in the right direction. Rep. Ron Paul, R-Texas, also used the "right direction" phrase, but he said he does not "fully endorse it."

Next: What's the next step in the Medicare overhaul? >>

Topic Alerts

You can get weekly email alerts on the topics below. Just click “Follow.”

Manage Alerts

Processing

Please wait...

progress bar, please wait

Tell Us WhatYou Think

Please leave your comment below.

Discounts & Benefits

From companies that meet the high standards of service and quality set by AARP.

Downloadable mobile app from AARP® Roadside Assistance from Allstate.

AARP Credit card from Chase

Members can earn 3% cash back on purchases with the AARP® Credit Card from Chase.

Member Benefits

Join or renew today! Members receive exclusive member benefits & affect social change.