Medicare Open Enrollment Ends Wednesday, Dec. 7. Learn More



Doctors on Reform—Many Voices, Many Views

Peter Basch, M.D., a primary care doctor in Washington, knows about soaring health care costs. At his office, just minutes from the Capitol, where health care reform is Congress’ hottest topic, he once allowed some of his patients to pay him with homegrown produce instead of money—applying a 19th-century solution to a 21st-century problem.

But, like most doctors, he’s now assessing a variety of new ideas to transform the country’s antiquated health care system. On Monday, President Obama addressed the American Medical Association in Chicago. The 250,000-member group has made it clear that it doesn’t see eye to eye with the president on some of his reform proposals. At the same time, other physician groups have taken stands that are publicly at odds with some of the AMA’s positions, showing that opinions on reform vary greatly among the nation’s 800,000 doctors.

Basch says he isn’t committed to any proposal: “The first response that most physicians have is, ‘I want to see what this really means. What’s it going to do for my patients?’ ”

On the other side of the country, David Evans, M.D., of Jefferson County, Ore., also sees hard times in health care. Just two weeks ago, a distraught 55-year-old patient with heart disease and diabetes came to his office after losing her employer health insurance when her work hours were cut. Evans, who waived her fee that day, says, “I worry about her ability to get her meds and care.” He agreed to space out her visits to every six months.

“What doctors want is to be able to provide the best care possible for their patients, and that’s difficult to do that when they don’t have insurance coverage,” says Evans, president of the National Physicians Alliance. The 20,000-member organization supports Obama’s call for a public insurance plan because, Evans says, it would offer affordable coverage to more Americans and compete with private insurers “to keep them honest.”

A wide range of views

Despite its initial opposition to Obama’s plan to offer a government insurance option, the AMA appeared to soften its stance, saying it was willing to consider variations of the plan now under consideration in Congress. But the publicity surrounding the group’s original response touched off a blistering public debate that revealed a wide range of divergent views on health care reform among the nation’s doctors.

And what they think matters. When the Clinton administration proposed sweeping health care reforms, the AMA helped defeat them. Now, though, other physician groups are speaking out in the renewed debate.

In his speech before the AMA, Obama said, “I need your help, doctors. To most Americans, you are the health care system. Americans—me included—just do what you recommend. That is why I will listen to you and work with you to pursue reform that works for you.”

What seems clear is that many doctors across the country, including the AMA, agree that big, basic reforms are necessary. “Like President Obama, the AMA is committed to health reform this year that provides all Americans with affordable, high-quality health care coverage,” the group said in a press release this week.

Generally, most doctors say they’d welcome reforms that would allow them to spend more time treating patients, relieve the threat and costs of malpractice lawsuits, and free them of burdensome paperwork. They also like proposals that would reward preventive care rather than emergency intervention.

Proposals for basic changes

After years of paying doctors based on the number of visits or procedures, there is widespread support in Congress for paying medical providers for excellent, effective care, not volume of work, a reform measure popular with many physicians.

“We couldn’t get much worse than we are now—and can’t afford to,” says Robert Lamberts, M.D., an internist in Augusta, Ga. “Right now, the system pays us more to do more, so that is what we get: more,” he adds. “The payment system has to change to encourage physicians and other providers to use the resources efficiently.”

One part of Obama’s speech to the AMA had doctors on their feet cheering. “With reform, we will ensure that you are being reimbursed in a thoughtful way tied to patient outcomes instead of relying on yearly negotiations about the sustainable growth rate formula that’s based on politics and the state of the federal budget in any given year,” he said. In recent years that formula has called for cutting Medicare payments to doctors by five percent a year, though every year Congress has acted to stave off the cuts at the last minute.

Interest in basic primary care

Many doctors also favor proposals that would provide incentives for newly graduated physicians—such as paying off medical education loans—to choose primary care over a specialty.

Topic Alerts

You can get weekly email alerts on the topics below. Just click “Follow.”

Manage Alerts


Please wait...

progress bar, please wait

Tell Us WhatYou Think

Please leave your comment below.


Discounts & Benefits

From companies that meet the high standards of service and quality set by AARP.

Walgreens 1 discount membership aarp

Members can earn 50 points per $1 spent on select health & wellness products at Walgreens.

member benefit aarp hear usa

Members save 15% on easy listening devices and more at the HearUSA Hearing Shop.

Eye Med 4 Membership Benefit AARP Discount

Members save up to 60% on eye exams and 30% on glasses at Target Optical.

Membership Benefits Discounts Email Genius

Brain boost? Get AARP email for access to memory exercises & more that help you focus.

Rewards for Good

Your Points Balance:

Learn More

Earn points for completing free online activities designed to enrich your life.

Find more ways to earn points

Redeem your points to save on merchandise, travel, and more.

Find more ways to redeem points