Alert
Close

Watch the NASCAR race on Sunday at Texas Motor Speedway. Join the Drive to End Hunger!

DONATE

Be part of the solution.

Help AARP Foundation win back opportunity for struggling Americans 50 and over.

Charity Rating

AARP Foundation earns high rating for accountability from a leading charity evaluator. Read

Connect with the
Foundation

Email:

foundation@aarp.org

 

Toll-free Nationwide:

888-OUR-AARP

(888-687-2277)

 

Toll-free TTY:

877-434-7598

 

AARP Foundation Tax ID

52-0794300

Jarvis v. First Resolution

AARP Asks Ohio Supreme Court to Hold Debt Collectors Liable for Abusive Practices

    

AARP is asking the Ohio Supreme Court to sanction a debt collector for bringing a lawsuit that the debtor alleges had no basis in the law and sought damages that were well in excess of those permitted by law. AARP is concerned that many debtors fall prey to aggressive tactics such as these and will find themselves paying massive debts they do not owe, forcing them to choose between food, shelter, medical care and payment of debts that actually do not exist.

Background

First Resolution is a debt collection firm that sued Sandra J. Taylor Jarvis to collect on a credit card debt it had purchased from Chase Bank.  Jarvis filed claims against First Resolution, alleging that it had engaged in deceptive practices illegal under Ohio and federal law, the suit was barred by the statute of limitations stated in the underlying credit contract, and it sought to collect an interest rate on the allegedly overdue funds of 24 percent, which was well in excess of that permitted by law.  

First Resolution withdrew its suit and the court dismissed Jarvis’ counter claims. Jarvis appealed in order to get a judgment regarding First Resolution’s allegedly deceptive practices.

AARP Foundation Litigation attorneys filed AARP’s  friend-of-the-court brief on behalf of  Jarvis detailing the deceptive practices used by debt collectors, the dangers these pose – particularly to older consumers and those on fixed incomes – that  literally can be life threatening when a debtor is forced to choose between paying for food, shelter, medical needs, or debt. The brief also discusses the business practices in the debt collection industry and its built in incentives for abuse. Numerous studies show that collectors often do not have sufficient evidence to support claims yet clog the courts with hundreds of thousands of collection lawsuits every year, knowing the vast majority of the judgments will be granted by default. Commonly, old debt is purchased in portfolios containing masses of accounts with each individual account costing only a few cents on the dollar.  The incentives are to press forward with cases regardless of the validity, practices which harm consumers as well as courts.

What’s at Stake


AARP has participated in other cases advocating for the interests of victims of debt collection abuses because the issues of abuse in the debt collection industry especially impact older people. People age 50 and above are incurring and amassing increasingly unaffordable levels of debt, often triggered by the need for immediate cash due to medical treatment. Older people are also extremely vulnerable to the tactics of and threats made by debt collection agencies and are fearful of challenging debts even if those debts are erroneous, old, or had actually been paid off. The bad data, record keeping, and collections practices in the debt collection industry cause consumer abuses of significant concern, particularly in a down economy where collectors are more zealous and debtors have even fewer resources.

Case Status


Jarvis v. First Resolution is before the Ohio Supreme Court, the state’s highest court.

Search Legal Advocacy

Find
Legal Cases

Find the most recent cases in which AFL has advocated in courts nationwide for the rights of older persons, and filed AARP’s amicus curiae (“friend of the court”) briefs that help courts decide precedent-setting cases.

Strengthening Law and Policy through
Legal Advocacy

Our legal advocacy initiatives  - conducted by AARP Foundation Litigation (AFL) - reflect more than 15 years of work in federal and state courts across the country. Through our efforts, we support the Foundation’s four priority areas: Hunger, Income, Housing and Isolation, and ensure that those 50 and older have a voice in the laws and policies that affect their daily lives.