Skip to content
 

FRAUD RESOURCE CENTER

Debt Collection Scams

En español | Debt collection regularly ranks among the top consumer complaints to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC). The agency notes a range of deceptive and abusive tactics used to get debtors to pay up, including repeated phone calls, verbal harangues, and threats to disclose debts to employers and family members.

But many Americans are confronted by a problem even scarier than aggressive debt collectors: aggressive fake debt collectors, who try to bully their targets into paying money they don’t owe.

Have you seen this scam?

Sign up for Watchdog Alerts for more tips on avoiding scams.

The FTC calls it “phantom debt collection.” You get a call from someone claiming to be a debt collector, or an attorney from a law firm with a legitimate-sounding name. The caller insists you have a delinquent payday loan, credit card balance or some other sort of consumer debt and demands immediate payment of hundreds or thousands of dollars. They may threaten arrest or other legal action, even warning that a police officer or process server is headed at that very moment to your home or workplace.

Occasionally such situations arise from mistaken identity: A legitimate debt collection agency slips up, confusing a consumer with a debtor who has a similar name (an error known as “debt tagging”). Often, though, it’s a scammer, combining bits of personal information harvested from sources such as old loan applications and hacked accounts to fabricate bogus debts that consumers might be deceived into thinking are real. Some large-scale operators package these phony liabilities into portfolios and sell them to debt brokers for collection.

In recent years, federal and state authorities have upped the pressure on abusive collectors and phantom-debt predators. A joint crackdown by the FTC, other federal agencies and authorities in 16 states produced more than 50 cases in 2019 and 2020, putting many collectors out of business and securing multimillion-dollar judgments.

But the problem remains widespread: In the first nine months of 2020 the FTC received more than 38,000 consumer reports of collectors using abusive or threatening tactics or trying to collect money that wasn't owed. 

Warning Signs

  • A supposed debt collector threatens to have you arrested, something the CFPB says legitimate collectors should not do.
  • The caller demands immediate payment.
  • The caller wants you to pay via wire transfer or prepaid debit card. These are methods favored by scammers because they’re difficult to trace.

Do's

  • Do insist on identification. Ask for the caller’s name, company, address, phone number and professional license number, which your state may require. 
  • Do demand information about the debt. Debt collectors are required by federal law to provide you with a written validation notice specifying how much you owe, the name of the original creditor and how to challenge the claim.
  • Do check your credit report after you hear from a suspicious collector — if a debt isn’t listed, that may be a sign of a scam. Through April 2021, you can get one free credit report per week from each of the three major reporting agencies, Equifax, Experian and TransUnion (see "More Resources" below).
  • Do a web search on the caller’s phone number. You may find complaints from other consumers that it belongs to a scam collection agency.

Don'ts

  • Don’t give any personal data to someone who claims to be a debt collector. A legitimate collection agency would have received that information from the creditor.
  • Don’t discuss the debt with someone who calls out of the blue. Demand that the caller provide the legally required written notice first.
  • Don’t make a payment you’re not sure you owe to get a collector off your back. Insist on verifying the debt claim.

More Resources

Updated September 29, 2020

About the Fraud Watch Network

Whether you have been personally affected by scams or fraud or are interested in learning more, the AARP Fraud Watch Network advocates on your behalf and equips you with the knowledge you need to feel more informed and confidently spot and avoid scams.

More From the Fraud Resource Center

Join the Discussion

0 | Add Yours

Please leave your comment below.

You must be logged in to leave a comment.