Alert
Close

Last chance! Play brain games for a chance to win $25,000. Enter the Brain Health Sweepstakes

AARP Membership: Just $16 a Year

Highlights

Open

Grocery Coupon Center

Powered by Coupons.com. Access to grocery coupons

Bad consumer experience?

Submit a complaint to AARP's consumer advocate

Geek Squad

Exclusive offers for members

Technical Icon

Spanish Preferred?

Visit aarp.org/espanol

Start a Business

Find the resources you need to start
or grow your own business

Bulletin

Where We Stand

Meeting the Needs of All Generations

We need to focus on helping people of all ages attain long-term health and financial security

  • Zoom
  • Print
  • Comments
  • Bookmark
  • Recommend

I have been greatly disturbed by the increasing number of articles promoting the myth that older Americans are committing "generational theft" in plain sight. This further perpetuates the notion that our society either cannot afford or cannot find a way to "promote the general welfare" of all its citizens. In this view, the old and the young are at war over limited resources — someone must win and someone must lose. This is not only insulting, it is pure folly and very dangerous.

Learn more about the future of Medicare and Social Security

We are not surprised that this argument is reemerging as Congress and the president wrestle with huge federal deficits, the budget and the future of Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid. We've seen it before, and each time the charges become more outrageous — from a generation gap to generational conflict, generational warfare and now generational theft.

While we are not surprised by these arguments, they must come as quite a shock to:

  • The 7 million children living with grandparents.

  • The 42 million Americans who are informal caregivers, most of whom take care of older family members.

  • The 7 million children who live in households that depend on Social Security to support the family.

  • The 5 million widows and widowers and 2 million children whose parents have died and who rely on Social Security survivors' benefits.

  • The 6.5 million people 50-plus who have told us they are concerned that Social Security and Medicare will not be there for their kids and grandkids.

  • The tens of millions of 50-plus Americans who, through their tax dollars and voluntary contributions, support our public schools, children's health programs and grandparent guardianship programs.

  • The older adults in AARP Experience Corps who serve as mentors and role models to young students across the country, helping kids boost their academic performance while enriching their own lives as volunteers.

In the real world, families prosper together. And we struggle together. The high cost of health care hurts everyone. The Great Recession hurt everyone. We need to focus on helping people of all ages attain long-term health and financial security and live their best lives, not argue over who is hurt or helped more. That doesn't solve the problems we face as a society; it only promotes conflict and encourages antagonism.

As Washington politicians debate how best to deal with our economic woes, slow the rising costs of health care and chart the future course of Social Security and Medicare, they should consider how policy proposals affect people along the lifespan continuum, not in terms of generational winners and losers.

For example, the proposed alternative for calculating Social Security cost-of-living adjustments — the chained CPI — reduces the increases over time. The impact of this change compounds as a person gets older, so it could have a devastating effect on older beneficiaries, and also on younger beneficiaries as they get older. In short, it's a bad deal for all.

We totally reject the notion that the generations are at war. We're better than that. Our challenge is to meet the needs of all generations at all ages.

A. Barry Rand is the CEO of AARP.

Also of Interest

See the AARP home page for deals, savings tips, trivia and more

Topic Alerts

You can get weekly email alerts on the topics below. Just click “Follow.”

Manage Alerts

Processing

Please wait...

progress bar, please wait
  • Zoom
  • Print
  • Comments
  • Bookmark
  • Recommend

Video Extra

WHAT THE HECK IS CHAINED CPI? David Certner, AARP’s legislative policy director, explains the budget proposal that could cut the value of your Social Security benefits.

Tell Us WhatYou Think

Please leave your comment below.

You must be signed in to comment.

Sign In | Register

More comments »

washington watch

AARP Advocacy

Discounts & Benefits

From companies that meet the high standards of service and quality set by AARP.

Auto Insurance

Members can receive lifetime renewability with AARP® Auto Insurance Program from The Hartford.

Note to see lawyer

Members receive a free, 45-minute consultation with Legal Services Network from Allstate.

Homeowners Insurance
Member Benefits

Members receive exclusive member benefits & affect social change. Join Today

Featured
Groups

Politics — Current Events

Speak out on the issues and controversies of the day. Discuss

Issues & Elections

Civil, bipartisan discussions of today's issues and topics of national interest. Discuss