Processing
Please Wait...
progress bar, please wait
Alert
Close

New! Boost your memory with AARP Brain Fitness. Try these fun exercises proven more effective than crosswords

AARP Membership: Just $16 a Year

Most Popular
Articles

Viewed

Recommended

Commented

Discounts & Benefits

Members can save up to 80% on gift certificates from more than 15,000 restaurants nationwide.

Members can get exclusive online access to hundreds of free printable grocery coupons from leading brands.

Advertisement

Message Boards Directory

Welcome to the AARP Discussion Board. Here you can talk with peers about current events ranging from Social Security to caring for your parents to the latest on health care reform. It is also the perfect place to exchange healthy eating recipes and job hunting tips.

 

These forums are for you to engage and have fun meeting new people. Just remember the community code: Be nice!

The Nanny State and Personal Responsibility
False
Government & Elections
The Nanny State and Personal Responsibility
<font face="arial, helvetica, sans-serif" size="1">Whether you're a red state Republican or a blue state Democrat, everyone is welcome &mdash; just remember to be civil.</font>
I come from what would be considered a lower middle class background. My parents bought what they could afford. They never over-extended themselves. I worked summers through high school and college a
0
Cat:d51398b3-89f9-463d-bf1b-4b885f02c9eeForum:af978875-5bc6-4b07-a6fb-b18062132f95
Cat:d51398b3-89f9-463d-bf1b-4b885f02c9eeForum:af978875-5bc6-4b07-a6fb-b18062132f95Discussion:043d5ab9-2796-4350-989d-4cf0c1be670a

Forums » Politics & Society » Government & Elections » The Nanny State and Personal Responsibility

You must be logged in to contribute. Log in | Register
 
 1 2 >> Last
Forums  »  Politics & Society  »  Government & Elections  »  The Nanny State and Personal Responsibility

The Nanny State and Personal Responsibility

posted at April 16, 2012 6:25 PM EDT
Posts: 471
First: December 21, 2011
Last: May 20, 2013

I come from what would be considered a lower middle class background. My parents bought what they could afford. They never over-extended themselves. I worked summers through high school and college and went to a local public college. I worked 16 hours a week as a lab aide to help pay for tuition. When we bought our home, we put down 20% and bought something that we could afford-not a McMansion. .
Now it seems there is this chorus, primarily from the left (OWS) etc, telling us that the government should pay for education (cancel all student loans), all medical care and that those that put $0 down on a mortgage for a home that they could in no way afford should be bailed out by the government. Where has personal responsibility gone? What about all those that are paying back student loans? What about those that have under water mortgages, but still continue to make payments? It seems to me that we have an administration in power that would much rather have us succomb to government dependence, than continue as the great nation that we once were.

Re: The Nanny State and Personal Responsibility

posted at April 16, 2012 7:32 PM EDT
Posts: 532
First: August 9, 2011
Last: May 22, 2013
Sure, a lot of Med students are paying for their education and you pay for that education everytime you make a doctor's visit.




n Response to The Nanny State and Personal Responsibility:
I come from what would be considered a lower middle class background. My parents bought what they could afford. They never over-extended themselves. I worked summers through high school and college and went to a local public college. I worked 16 hours a week as a lab aide to help pay for tuition. When we bought our home, we put down 20% and bought something that we could afford-not a McMansion. . Now it seems there is this chorus, primarily from the left (OWS) etc, telling us that the government should pay for education (cancel all student loans), all medical care and that those that put $0 down on a mortgage for a home that they could in no way afford should be bailed out by the government. Where has personal responsibility gone? What about all those that are paying back student loans? What about those that have under water mortgages, but still continue to make payments? It seems to me that we have an administration in power that would much rather have us succomb to government dependence, than continue as the great nation that we once were.
Posted by Labrat64

Re: The Nanny State and Personal Responsibility

posted at April 16, 2012 9:51 PM EDT
Posts: 938
First: December 1, 2011
Last: May 7, 2013
The  left wants nanny state, the right wants bombing other nations.
As both need money and our county is almost broke that insanity will not last long.

The only SANE candidate who dares to address that is Ron Paul however the mainstream tv somehow managed to convince some Americans that he's crazy...

Re: The Nanny State and Personal Responsibility

posted at April 17, 2012 9:44 AM EDT
Posts: 471
First: December 21, 2011
Last: May 20, 2013
IAstra, I think you'll agree that we cannot keep going on the way we are. A third party candidate will only assure 4 more years of destruction to our nation. Obama has already reassured Russia's Medvedev that he will have more flexibility during a second term. What that means is more legislation by "executive decree", bypassing congress. Once we've reached a tipping point in which more than 50% of voters are on the dole, there's no turning back. We could end up like Greece.
 n Response to Re: The Nanny State and Personal Responsibility:
The  left wants nanny state, the right wants bombing other nations. As both need money and our county is almost broke that insanity will not last long. The only SANE candidate who dares to address that is Ron Paul however the mainstream tv somehow managed to convince some Americans that he's crazy...
Posted by Astra2012

Re: The Nanny State and Personal Responsibility

posted at April 17, 2012 9:50 AM EDT
Posts: 471
First: December 21, 2011
Last: May 20, 2013
I At least they're paying back what they owe and not trying to stick it to someone else  (namely us taxpayers). Besides, what's wrong with paying for your debts with money you earn?
n Response to Re: The Nanny State and Personal Responsibility:
Sure, a lot of Med students are paying for their education and you pay for that education everytime you make a doctor's visit. n Response to The Nanny State and Personal Responsibility :
Posted by creppelrm

Re: The Nanny State and Personal Responsibility

posted at April 17, 2012 11:03 AM EDT
Posts: 532
First: August 9, 2011
Last: May 22, 2013
Yes they are sticking us with the cost, universities, doctors, hospitals and INSURANCE compaines are sticking us with the cost.  Cost just continues to rise on everything not just education, doctors, but food, fuel etc, but wages for the average person is still the same.  Everythling continues to rise but Republicans blind the people worried about taxes.  What is wrong with taxing the rich who are  profiting from our situation?  Do you really think that the Big Oil execuetives are going to go bankrupt when the rest of the country does?   Cost on everything continues to rise, that will be the cause of bankruptcy more than just one man everyone would like to blame it on. Greed will be our downfall. You also have a story of what you paid for your education.  Well there are over 300 million people in this country and everyone has a story.  It may help you to listen to theirs also you may be surprised what you hear. 

n Response to Re: The Nanny State and Personal Responsibility:
I At least they're paying back what they owe and not trying to stick it to someone else  (namely us taxpayers). Besides, what's wrong with paying for your debts with money you earn? n Response to Re: The Nanny State and Personal Responsibility :
Posted by Labrat64

Re: The Nanny State and Personal Responsibility

posted at April 17, 2012 2:00 PM EDT
Posts: 938
First: December 1, 2011
Last: May 7, 2013
In Response to Re: The Nanny State and Personal Responsibility:
IAstra, I think you'll agree that we cannot keep going on the way we are. A third party candidate will only assure 4 more years of destruction to our nation. Obama has already reassured Russia's Medvedev that he will have more flexibility during a second term. What that means is more legislation by "executive decree", bypassing congress. Once we've reached a tipping point in which more than 50% of voters are on the dole, there's no turning back. We could end up like Greece.  n Response to Re: The Nanny State and Personal Responsibility :
Posted by Labrat64


Yes, I very much agree we would end up like  Greece with "business as usual".
What is scary however is the realization how much we, the American people, have lost in terms of our rights and of our say in the country direction...

People protested the war in Iraq but it happened anyway and  they paid for it in money and lives.
but some rich people got richer...

it also scares me to think that our president, whether Obama or Romney, would only be a puppet in someone's hands, as most of our congresspeople are.
Maybe it started with Bush Jr who allowed someone else to "lead us"...

Re: The Nanny State and Personal Responsibility

posted at April 18, 2012 7:55 AM EDT
Posts: 471
First: December 21, 2011
Last: May 20, 2013
IWhat I'm trying to say is that we've reached a point where people believe that government is the answer to everything. Individual responsibility has gone by the wayside. Groups like OWS expect the government to be responsible for healthcare, education, housing and just about everything else. What made this country great was the innovative people that were willing to take risks. To take risks there must be incentives. Taxing the hell out of people that take rsks, just removes this incentive. Wealth redistribution (the Obama plan) results in a society that just looks for handouts, much like most of Socialist Europe. 
n Response to Re: The Nanny State and Personal Responsibility:
Yes they are sticking us with the cost, universities, doctors, hospitals and INSURANCE compaines are sticking us with the cost.  Cost just continues to rise on everything not just education, doctors, but food, fuel etc, but wages for the average person is still the same.  Everythling continues to rise but Republicans blind the people worried about taxes.  What is wrong with taxing the rich who are  profiting from our situation?  Do you really think that the Big Oil execuetives are going to go bankrupt when the rest of the country does?   Cost on everything continues to rise, that will be the cause of bankruptcy more than just one man everyone would like to blame it on. Greed will be our downfall. You also have a story of what you paid for your education.  Well there are over 300 million people in this country and everyone has a story.  It may help you to listen to theirs also you may be surprised what you hear.  n Response to Re: The Nanny State and Personal Responsibility :
Posted by creppelrm

Re: The Nanny State and Personal Responsibility

posted at April 19, 2012 9:36 AM EDT
Posts: 12532
First: February 29, 2008
Last: May 17, 2013
In Response to Re: The Nanny State and Personal Responsibility:
IWhat I'm trying to say is that we've reached a point where people believe that government is the answer to everything. Individual responsibility has gone by the wayside. Groups like OWS expect the government to be responsible for healthcare, education, housing and just about everything else. What made this country great was the innovative people that were willing to take risks. To take risks there must be incentives. Taxing the hell out of people that take rsks, just removes this incentive. Wealth redistribution (the Obama plan) results in a society that just looks for handouts, much like most of Socialist Europe.  n Response to Re: The Nanny State and Personal Responsibility :
Posted by Labrat64


The GOVT has to be the answer....if you think this recession is bad----.who bailed  Wall Street out just recently to avert another 1929 DEPRESSION  if it wasn't the GOVT.     Because of the recent recession, tax collections have fallen to their lowest level as a share of the economy in 60 years.  

40% of our nation's workers are service-oriented employees and about time they get $20 an hour so they can be more self-reliant. But the republicans won't even raise the minimum wage to $10 an hour cause it will take more money out of THEIR pockets for products and services. Then people complain about paying taxes.....and when these same people need soc security some will complain about that too.         
   
RELY ON YOURSELF ???    You must grow your own food then....never rely on others at all .  The days of the prairie, of the frontier, of brave pioneers living isolated against overwhelming odds, are pretty much over .. growing our own food---raising our own barns.... .We have become very much interdependent over the past 100 years, and we cannot live in isolation anymore. We will fail collectively, or succeed collectively. You rely on your fellow man for your needs ....then he leans on you for his needs too ...that's the way it will only work. We are in this together. We contribute to society if we can and should do what we can for ourselves but there are limitations.   When conservatives want "everyone to rely on themselves"...then they must first seek means or ways for society to actually be able to accomplish that.
The top
400 earners in the U.S. paid an average tax rate of 18 percent, according to a Bloomberg TV report. And though that's a far lower rate than the 26.5 percent that many families making less than $100,000 pay annually in taxes, some of America's super-rich have been able to whittle their tax bill down even more, paying a tax rate as low as one percent, according to Bloomberg. But billionaires aren't the only ones that use loopholes to pay lower taxes. Thirty of America's most profitable corporations used rules like the "active financing exception" -- allowing corporations to sidestep paying taxes on overseas profits if they were derived by "actively financing" some activity or deal -- to pay less than zero in income taxes, according to a recent report from the Center for Tax Justice.
  

Re: The Nanny State and Personal Responsibility

posted at April 19, 2012 11:21 AM EDT
Posts: 532
First: August 9, 2011
Last: May 22, 2013
You got it right Jan,
At this moment we need Govt. to do something about these insurance companies who are taking advantage of the people that are being hit by natural disasters, ill health etc.  Insurance companies are in business for one reason  "MAKE MONEY".  Their lawyers draw up policies that are hard for the average person to understand and naturally when a person really needs it, it doesn't exist. Anyone who doesn't see that they need to be regulated like as you said "WALL STREET" from taking advantage of the people are also taking advantage of the people.  The real NANNY STATE are these republicans who living lavish lifestyles while they and their rich friends manipulate the general populace. 

n Response to Re: The Nanny State and Personal Responsibility:
In Response to Re: The Nanny State and Personal Responsibility : The GOVT has to be the answer....if you think this recession is bad----.who bailed  Wall Street out just recently to avert another 1929 DEPRESSION  if it wasn't the GOVT.     Because of the recent recession, tax collections have fallen to their lowest level as a share of the economy in 60 years.   40% of our nation's workers are service-oriented employees and about time they get $20 an hour so they can be more self-reliant. But the republicans won't even raise the minimum wage to $10 an hour cause it will take more money out of THEIR pockets for products and services. Then people complain about paying taxes.....and when these same people need soc security some will complain about that too.              RELY ON YOURSELF ???    You must grow your own food then....never rely on others at all .  The days of the prairie, of the frontier, of brave pioneers living isolated against overwhelming odds, are pretty much over .. growing our own food---raising our own barns.... .We have become very much interdependent over the past 100 years, and we cannot live in isolation anymore. We will fail collectively, or succeed collectively. You rely on your fellow man for your needs ....then he leans on you for his needs too ...that's the way it will only work. We are in this together. We contribute to society if we can and should do what we can for ourselves but there are limitations.   When conservatives want "everyone to rely on themselves"...then they must first seek means or ways for society to actually be able to accomplish that. The top 400 earners in the U.S. paid an average tax rate of 18 percent , according to a Bloomberg TV report. And though that's a far lower rate than the 26.5 percent that many families making less than $100,000 pay annually in taxes, some of America's super-rich have been able to whittle their tax bill down even more, paying a tax rate as low as one percent, according to Bloomberg. But billionaires aren't the only ones that use loopholes to pay lower taxes. Thirty of America's most profitable corporations used rules like the "active financing exception" -- allowing corporations to sidestep paying taxes on overseas profits if they were derived by "actively financing" some activity or deal -- to pay less than zero in income taxes , according to a recent report from the Center for Tax Justice.   
Posted by JANMB

 1 2 >> Last

Forums » Politics & Society » Government & Elections » The Nanny State and Personal Responsibility