Processing
Please Wait...
progress bar, please wait
Alert
Close

New! Boost your memory with AARP Brain Fitness. Try these fun exercises proven more effective than crosswords

AARP Membership: Just $16 a Year

Most Popular
Articles

Viewed

Recommended

Commented

Discounts & Benefits

Members can save up to 80% on gift certificates from more than 15,000 restaurants nationwide.

Members can get exclusive online access to hundreds of free printable grocery coupons from leading brands.

Advertisement

Message Boards Directory

Welcome to the AARP Discussion Board. Here you can talk with peers about current events ranging from Social Security to caring for your parents to the latest on health care reform. It is also the perfect place to exchange healthy eating recipes and job hunting tips.

 

These forums are for you to engage and have fun meeting new people. Just remember the community code: Be nice!

Scottrade Greed
False
Scams & Fraud
Scottrade Greed
<font face="arial, helvetica, sans-serif" size="1"><div>Learn what are the lastest list of scams and how you can prevent your identity from being stolen. Protect yourself from scams, whether they be phone scams, online scams or in-person.&nbsp;</div></font>
Hi, &nbsp; I recently became the executor of an estate of a family friend who passed away. &nbsp;He had investment accounts at both Scottrade and Schwab. &nbsp;I went to both offices to convert these
0
Cat:827966ee-6d39-4ef7-98a5-0157a43092f8Forum:b90a5c24-5453-42fa-b1f5-851b8a98e4aa
Cat:827966ee-6d39-4ef7-98a5-0157a43092f8Forum:b90a5c24-5453-42fa-b1f5-851b8a98e4aaDiscussion:c8b4e273-e7f7-4afc-94db-62303823c4de

Forums » Money » Scams & Fraud » Scottrade Greed

You must be logged in to contribute. Log in | Register
 
Forums  »  Money  »  Scams & Fraud  »  Scottrade Greed

Scottrade Greed

posted at September 11, 2012 9:05 PM EDT
Posts: 1
First: September 11, 2012
Last: September 11, 2012

Hi,

  I recently became the executor of an estate of a family friend who passed away.  He had investment accounts at both Scottrade and Schwab.  I went to both offices to convert these accounts into estate accounts.  Interestingly, the Scottrade officer told me that I could not trade online (per Scottrade policy) for estate accounts, translation - I'll have to pay $27 per broker assisted trade vs. $7.95 per online trade.  There were 7 holding at Scottrade thus a difference of 7 x $27 = $189 vs. 7 x $7.95 = $56, thus Scottrades' "policy" just netted them an extra  $133, or so I thought.  After I sold the holdings and received the trade confirmations, I was billed almost $700 in commissions on 7 trades.  Apparently, an estate account is considered a “Traditional” account and thus commissions are billed at $27 + $0.02/share.  This was never disclosed to me either in writing or verbally.  I’ve called twice to complain stating that full disclosure in investment is mandatory only to be told that there is no way to prove what was/was not disclosed verbally. 

 Had I’d known the commission was this high I would have just transferred the shares out of the account in-kind.

 With Schwab, I paid $8.95 per trade, so I know this isn’t a Wall Street policy, just a Scottrade policy.

 

Does anyone know how I might fight this?

 

Thanks for reading.

Re: Scottrade Greed

posted at September 13, 2012 3:56 AM EDT
Posts: 4
First: September 9, 2012
Last: September 22, 2012
Hi,
If you google "SEC submit a tip", your first result should be the web page for the SEC's whistleblower program. On that web page, you can click on a link to report your complaint online. Because of a change in law this year, you can now become eligible to receive a financial reward from the SEC if they recover enough of a fine from the company.

To get your money back directly from the company, you may need to get a lawyer to write a threatening letter. If you need help finding a fraud attorney, you might google the nationwide non-profit attorney referral service for fraud victims called "Taxpayers Against Fraud". Some of those attorneys might take on a case of this nature without charging you an up-front fee.

Andy Prough, CFE
Kyle, TX

Re: Scottrade Greed

posted at September 28, 2012 5:29 PM EDT
Posts: 711
First: December 19, 2008
Last: September 28, 2012
In Response to Scottrade Greed:

What a rip!  Scottrade is headquartered in my state, Arizona, known for its corporate-friendly and consumer-unfriendly rules and laws.

I would complain to  my corporation commissioner.  Meanwhile, hopefully this shenanigan will cost Scottrade a lot more in lost business than it ripped off you.

Hi,   I recently became the executor of an estate of a family friend who passed away.  He had investment accounts at both Scottrade and Schwab.  I went to both offices to convert these accounts into estate accounts.  Interestingly, the Scottrade officer told me that I could not trade online (per Scottrade policy) for estate accounts, translation - I'll have to pay $27 per broker assisted trade vs. $7.95 per online trade.  There were 7 holding at Scottrade thus a difference of 7 x $27 = $189 vs. 7 x $7.95 = $56, thus Scottrades' "policy" just netted them an extra  $133, or so I thought.  After I sold the holdings and received the trade confirmations, I was billed almost $700 in commissions on 7 trades.  Apparently, an estate account is considered a “Traditional” account and thus commissions are billed at $27 + $0.02/share.  This was never disclosed to me either in writing or verbally.  I’ve called twice to complain stating that full disclosure in investment is mandatory only to be told that there is no way to prove what was/was not disclosed verbally.   Had I’d known the commission was this high I would have just transferred the shares out of the account in-kind.  With Schwab, I paid $8.95 per trade, so I know this isn’t a Wall Street policy, just a Scottrade policy.   Does anyone know how I might fight this?   Thanks for reading.
Posted by PRinCO

Forums » Money » Scams & Fraud » Scottrade Greed