Deliver Help and Hope to Hungry Seniors This Thanksgiving Season. Donate

Medical ID Theft

Thieves can use your info to access your meds and get treatment.

With as many as 9 million Americans victimized by identity theft each year, according to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), there’s good reason to monitor and protect those items essential to your life—your credit cards, bank accounts, credit history, driver’s license and Social Security number.

But while the rapid growth of ID theft has spurred a flurry of credit-monitoring services and greater awareness of protecting financial records, less attention has been paid to perhaps an equally dangerous crime—medical identity theft, which can compromise life itself.

Medical identity theft occurs when someone uses your name or other parts of your identity—such as your health insurance—to obtain health care services for themselves or make false claims for medical treatment. Not only can you can be stuck for those expenses, leading to your own financial ruin, but the scam can jeopardize your own future treatment.

Until now, only about 250,000 Americans have been victimized by medical identity theft, according to FTC statistics—one reason, perhaps, is that this crime has largely flown under the radar. But a new government report says that medical identity theft is “an emerging issue that raises concerns for consumers, health care providers, health plans, government, and others.”

With Obama administration efforts to computerize patient health records—part of the economic stimulus package—some experts suggest that e-records (EHRs) can provide an even greater “open window” for this crime. And older Americans are perhaps most vulnerable.

“People 50 and older are at the greatest risk, because they often have some kind of government-issued insurance, such as Medicare or Medicaid,” says Pam Dixon of the World Privacy Forum, a consumer protection advocacy group. “That’s a big lure for the scammers, because the system is so large and automated that the government doesn’t really do medical insurance fraud alerts.”

In addition to fraud that can damage your finances, medical identity can lead to getting the wrong medications or treatment. Several years ago, Janet, who does not want her real name revealed, noticed that her pharmacy printed the wrong address on a prescription bottle. When she received a letter from her insurance company asking her to confirm a four-page list of drugs prescribed in her name, she realized she was a victim. Most of the drugs listed were narcotics she’d never taken.

“I thought maybe there was some mix-up, two people with the same name cross-referenced in the computer somehow,” she recalls. But for years, apparently, someone else had been seeing dozens of doctors—using Janet’s name and insurance number.

Because victims may not get a bill, medical identity theft can be harder to detect than other financial identity crimes. And once suspected, it’s harder to fix. That’s because there could be problems pinpointing the source of bogus information that could be held by various parties—doctors, insurers, pharmacies and labs. And although patients have a legal right to request amendments to their records, doctors and insurance companies can easily say no, wanting to do their investigation before altering records.

To prevent medical identity theft, more health care facilities are asking patients for picture identification. But some scammers with access to private health records can get fake picture IDs of their victims. That means it’s often up to you to take measures to protect your medical identity. Here’s how:

  • Ask your doctors to make copies of everything in your medical file (you may have to pay for them); keep the files updated for a protective “paper trail.” Ask, too, for an “accounting of disclosures,” which shows who accessed your records.
  • Review all correspondence from medical insurers, including the Explanation of Benefits statement—those that say “this is not a bill.” If you see a doctor’s name or treatment date that isn’t familiar, speak up.


  • Once a year, ask for a listing of benefits paid out in your name. Make sure it’s accurate. Be on the lookout for any changes in your billing address.


  • Be leery of facilities advertising free treatment and goodies. They could be a front for medical identity thieves trying to get your health records and insurance information.


  • Monitor your credit report, looking for reports of medical debt, with credit reporting bureaus Equifax, Experian and TransUnion. Under law, every American is entitled to three free credit history reports per year at A credit score costs extra.


  • Guard your health insurance card and number as carefully as you would a credit card or bank account number. Never provide your insurance information to telemarketers, and beware of “shoulder surfing” as you provide personal information in health care settings with other people nearby.


If you note errors or suspect identity theft, immediately call the billing physician and request that your file be amended. Also, notify the office of your state attorney general and the regional office of the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, if you receive those services.

Sid Kirchheimer is the author of "Scam-Proof Your Life" (AARP Books/Sterling). Katharine Greider is a freelance health writer and author of "The Big Fix."


Join the Discussion

0 | Add Yours

Please leave your comment below.

You must be logged in to leave a comment.

AARP Membership

Discounts & Benefits

    Next Article

    Read This