Alert
Close

Think you know AARP? What you don't know about us may surprise you. Discover all the 'Real Possibilities'

HIGHLIGHTS

Open

2014 NATIONAL EVENT

Health & Wellness
AARP Auto Buying Program

DRIVER SAFETY

Piggy bank on the road - AARP Driver Safety

Take the new AARP Smart Driver Course!

Contests and
Sweeps

Safe Driving in 2014 Sweepstakes

Learn how AARP Driver Safety can help you stay safe—and enter for a chance to win $1,000. See official rules. 

Download the ipad App

AARP-iPad-ePub-app

KEEP BRAIN ACTIVE!

AARP Games - Play Now!

AARP Books

Medicare for Dummies book cover

Get the answers you need, from Patricia Barry, AARP's Ask Ms. Medicare

Most Popular

Viewed

share your Thoughts

Reader stories help us fine-tune our education efforts and strengthen our calls for action on issues that matter most to you. We read and learn from every story and may use yours (with permission) to brief legislators, inspire other readers and more. Please share your story with us. Do

Top Republican and Liberal Democrat Seek Medicare Compromise

They say plan would preserve Medicare, allow flexibility

A liberal senator and a conservative Republican have teamed up to try to cut through the political noise about Medicare reform by offering a plan they think could win over both sides.

The proposal by House Budget Chairman Paul Ryan, R-Wis., and Sen. Ron Wyden, D-Ore., would offer older people a set amount of money to pay for private health insurance but also would give them the option of sticking with the traditional Medicare program.

See also: AARP on Wyden-Ryan Medicare proposal.

Wyden says the proposal satisfies Democrats’ desire to preserve traditional Medicare and Republicans’ desire for market-driven competition.

“There’s a window of opportunity here,” Wyden said Thursday. He added, though, that a “high decibel” debate is about to break out with the coming election year. “We know there’s a campaign ahead … But at some point, you’ve got to start paving the way for the future.”

Ryan agreed on the urgency. “Medicare is going bankrupt. The status quo is the greatest threat to seniors,” he said.

The plan quickly drew fire.

For instance, the Obama administration opposes the plan.

White House spokesman Jay Carney said the Wyden-Ryan proposal could, over time, cause the traditional Medicare program to “wither on the vine,” because it would raise premiums, forcing many seniors to leave traditional Medicare and join private plans.  And it would shift costs from the government to seniors.
 
“At the end of the day, “ he said, “this plan would end Medicare as we know it for millions of seniors.  The Wyden-Ryan proposal is the wrong way to reform Medicare.  That’s our position.”

Lauren Weiner, spokeswoman for the progressive group Americans United for Change, called it “coupon care” and charged that the plan would increase participants’ out-of-pocket costs. “Leaving seniors to the mercy of the private insurance industry is just plain cruel,” she said.

That group also called the plan “lipstick on a pig” because it is very similar to the controversial plan Ryan presented earlier this year. There are two major differences from Ryan’s original proposal: The new plan would allow seniors to choose traditional Medicare and it would not automatically pay for shortfalls through higher costs for participants.

Rep. Pete Stark, D-Calif., called the plan an end to “Medicare as we know it, plain and simple. If these two get their way, senior citizens’ health coverage will depend on what big insurance offers and what seniors — most of them on modest, fixed incomes — can afford. That combination will jeopardize health and economic security for seniors.”

But Bob Moffit, senior fellow at the Heritage Foundation’s Center for Policy Innovation, says "Traditional Medicare is ending anyway." One consequence of the congressional supercommittee’s failure to reach a larger agreement is that Medicare providers now face a 2 percent cut. Further, the Affordable Care Act passed last year trims future spending for the private Medicare Advantage plans by $500 billion over the next decade.

“Ryan and Wyden are putting Medicare on a budget, but so is the current law,” he says.

By creating competition between private insurers for Medicare customers, prices will be driven down, Moffit says.

AARP Executive Vice President Nancy LeaMond said her organization is waiting to see more details. "AARP continues to review the Wyden-Ryan proposal, and just as with any proposal, we will examine whether it would reduce access to care, whether it will result in more cost shifting to older Americans, and whether it will improve health care quality and delivery."

Next: How does the plan work? >>

Topic Alerts

You can get weekly email alerts on the topics below. Just click “Follow.”

Manage Alerts

Processing

Please wait...

progress bar, please wait

Tell Us WhatYou Think

Please leave your comment below.

Discounts & Benefits

From companies that meet the high standards of service and quality set by AARP.

Woman trying on glasses in optometrists shop

Members save up to 60% on eye exams and 30% on glasses at JCPenney Optical.

Prescription medication spilling out of bottle

Members get a free Rx card from AARP® Prescription Discounts provided by Catamaran.

AngiesList

Members can save 25% to 45% on their Angie's List membership.

Caregiving walking

Caregiving can be a lonely journey, but AARP offers resources that can help.