Alert
Close

Join us at AARP's 2015 Life@50+ National Event and Expo in sunny Miami.  Learn more

HIGHLIGHTS

Open

learning centers

Get smart strategies for managing health conditions.


Arthritis

Heart Disease

Diabetes

Most Popular

Viewed

Some States Challenge New Health Care Law

Legal expert dismisses challenges as “political theater.”

Summary:

• State pushback to new federal health law picking up some steam
• More than a dozen attorneys general have filed a lawsuit
• Courts usually side with federal government in such disputes

The Commonwealth of Virginia, home to founding fathers and the country’s first English settlement, is chasing history once again. It is at the epicenter of a movement in the nation’s courthouses and statehouses to derail landmark federal health care legislation just signed into law.

Even before the federal legislation was signed, Virginia became the first state in the nation to enact a law blocking a critical component of the health care legislation—the requirement that nearly everyone buy insurance or pay a penalty. One other state, Idaho, has since approved a similar law. Lawmakers in more than 30 other states are considering similar legislation, and Arizonans will vote on a statewide ballot measure in November that would have the same effect. Virginia’s attorney general also became one of the first of more than a dozen state attorneys general to file lawsuits challenging the new federal law.

Legal scholars say these tactics won’t work. But that hasn’t stopped opponents from using legislation and lawsuits to continue their protest against health care reform.

“These are not serious legal challenges,” said Timothy S. Jost, Washington and Lee University School of Law professor. “They are political theater.”

Virginia Attorney General Ken Cuccinelli, R, said the commonwealth is in a unique position to sue because it already has a law in place that conflicts with the new federal statute. He acknowledged that courts usually side with the federal government in disputes between federal and state law. But he said this case is unique because the health care bill is “unconstitutional.”

Jost disagreed, saying the “states cannot pass laws nullifying federal law. We fought a Civil War over that.”

While these challenges may be more symbolic than substantive at the federal level, health care advocates said the efforts could have unintended consequences at the state level.

In Wyoming, for instance, supporters of health care reform argued that state legislation would jeopardize federal Medicaid matching funds, strip away health care consumer protections and limit lawmakers’ abilities to pass future health care reforms. Their arguments helped defeat efforts in the Wyoming legislature.

That was in February. Now Tim Summers, AARP Wyoming state director, said the health care reform repeal movement has gained so much momentum that victories, like the one in Wyoming, may be difficult to achieve.

“Before the health care reform vote in Congress, I would have said this was probably a train that could be stopped in some states, especially those with more politically moderate legislatures,” Summers said. “But after the vote, the country seems more polarized, and this train may be more difficult to stop.”

Even so, AARP remains “committed to implementing the promise of national health care reform in every state across the United States because it’s good for our members,” said JoAnn Lamphere, AARP state government relations director for health and long-term care. “Health care reform strengthens the Medicare program, and it provides assurances that nearly every American will have access to affordable and secure health coverage, which has never happened in America before.”

In Idaho, for instance, AARP “fought tooth and nail” to defeat the Idaho Health Freedom Act, but the measure was signed into law March 17, said David Irwin, AARP Idaho director of communications. It says state residents “shall be free to choose or decline any mode of securing health care services without penalty or threat of penalty.”

“This is the year that every member of the Idaho Legislature and the governor are up for re-election,” Irwin said. “They view this issue as one they can use to their benefit on the campaign trail.”

Topic Alerts

You can get weekly email alerts on the topics below. Just click “Follow.”

Manage Alerts

Processing

Please wait...

progress bar, please wait

Tell Us WhatYou Think

Please leave your comment below.

Discounts & Benefits

From companies that meet the high standards of service and quality set by AARP.

Grandson (8-9) whispering to grandfather, close-up

Members can save 20% on hearing aids with the AARP® Hearing Care Program provided by HearUSA.

AARP/Walgreens Wellness Bus Stops in Clarksdale, MS

Members can get exclusive points offers from Walgreens and Duane Reade.

Member Benefits

Join or renew today! AARP members receive exclusive member benefits & affect social change.

Rewards for Good

Your Points Balance:

Learn More

Earn points for completing free online activities designed to enrich your life.

Find more ways to earn points

Redeem your points to save on merchandise, travel, and more.

Find more ways to redeem points