Last chance – give now. Before 2014 ends, help struggling seniors. Donate

Movie Review: 'Oz the Great and Powerful'

James Franco charms as the Wizard in Disney's adventure down the Yellow Brick Road

And this is where Oz the Great and Powerful begins to break down around the edges. This film is not, as are most Oz versions, a reimagining of the Oz myth. 

Oz the Great and Powerful intends to set itself down right next to the MGM classic, enlarging not just on themes and characters created by L. Frank Baum in his Oz books, but also on the unique vision filmed more than 70 years ago by the wizards of MGM. That bold intent is declared from the outset, in a black-and-white prologue that yields to color only when the Wizard's balloon arrives in Oz. And it's repeated throughout as we glimpse the art deco-inspired Emerald City, an abortive musical number in Munchkinland and the measured march of the Wicked Witch's guards.

There is genius in Oz the Great and Powerful, to be sure, but because we've been down this very same vision of the Yellow Brick Road so many times before, the creative stakes are set so high that anything less than a modern-day classic becomes something of a letdown.

Oz the Great and Powerful does add one truly wonderful character to the cinematic legacy of Oz: the China Girl, a child made of fine bone china, orphaned when the Wicked Witch's army ransacked her home, a place called China Town. It's no insult to Oz's flesh-and-blood actors to say the animated China Girl, delicate and sweet, gives the film's most touchingly real performance. We glimpse the young actress who gives her voice, Joey King (first seen as a child in a wheelchair in the Kansas prologue), a poignant foreshadowing of China Girl's emotional and physical fragility.

If you see Oz the Great and Powerful with a little girl, she will emerge from the theater wanting a China Girl of her own. And you will want to give her one.

And that made me realize what was missing from Oz the Great and Powerful, and the reason why, no matter how nobly and respectfully it tries to build on the 1939 version, the film remains a mere echo of it. What's missing is Dorothy — not Judy Garland, but the girl herself. At the heart of The Wizard of Oz is Dorothy's oft-stated desire to go home. It's what propels her along the Yellow Brick Road; it's what compels her to hunt down the Wicked Witch.

Franco's Wizard has no desire to go back to the black-and-white dust bowl that is Kansas. In Oz, he's virtually worshipped and certainly rich beyond his wildest dreams. Back in '39, the Tin Man yearned for a heart; the Scarecrow wanted a brain. Here, Oz's monkey sidekick is bound to him by an ill-advised oath, and even the sweet little China Girl is motivated by a thirst for revenge against the Wicked Witch.

Oz the Great and Powerful has brains to spare. But as thrilling and ingeniously conceived as it is, this Oz never quite finds its heart.

Tell Us WhatYou Think

Please leave your comment below.

Movies for Grownups Radio

Download weekly podcasts of celebrity interviews, entertainment news and more. Listen

Movies for Grownups Awards

AARP honors the films and filmmakers who make the movies we want to see. Read


Discounts & Benefits

From companies that meet the high standards of service and quality set by AARP.

Cirque Du Soleil

Members save up to 20% on live Cirque du Soleil shows with their AARP membership card.

Member Benefit AARP Regal 2

Members pay $8 for Regal ePremiere tickets purchased online. Conditions apply.

Movies Unlimited

Members save 10% on purchases of DVDs & Blu-ray discs from Movies Unlimited.

Member Benefits

Join or renew today! Members receive exclusive member benefits & affect social change.