Older Workers Struggle Through Financial Crisis
In the wake of today’s economic crisis, job fairs frequently draw as many older workers and retirees as high school and college grads. Job seekers of all ages and skill levels have flooded the employment pool with older workers showing up in increasingly larger numbers.
Lack of savings, dwindling 401(k) and nest egg investments, combined with increasing health care costs and day-to-day expenses have prodded some near-retirees to stay on the job. Similar factors have drawn others well into retirement back into the labor market. They’re joined by growing numbers of jobless downsizing casualties; many of them mid-life and older workers who aren’t old enough to retire. They still have responsibilities, perhaps dependent children, aging parents or other major financial obligations.
Financial turmoil is squeezing everyone regardless of age. People desperately need jobs. This climate has prompted some to sound the false alarm of generational warfare as unemployed older job seekers increase while their employed counterparts hold tightly to jobs. It’s a misguided charge, pitting old against young and exacerbating tensions during a challenging time.
Teresa Ghilarducci, authority on retirement economics, professor and author of When I’m Sixty-Four, says, “In a bad labor market, different groups perceive that they’re being discriminated against when the real problem is they’re being mistreated by the overall economy.”
In a landscape littered with foreclosures, bankruptcies, layoffs, company closings and falling stocks, unemployment is not the option of choice for traditional working-age men and women, and increasingly, not for many retirees.
Overall, national unemployment is at a quarter-century high and continues to rise among all age groups. However, in recent months, the greatest increase has been among workers 55+, 10.7 percent in March – considerably higher than the 4.9 percent for the entire workforce. Over the past several years, length of unemployment has consistently lasted about five weeks or longer, on average, for 55+ workers than for younger age groups.
Once older workers lose jobs, research shows it’s much harder for them to find new ones than for younger applicants. Some eventually give up and drop out of the job market, falling into a Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) category called ‘discouraged workers.’
The hurdles loom large for all job seekers in the current market, but the specter of age discrimination weighs heavily on older workers, underscored recently in the New York Times’ “Longer Unemployment for Those 45 and Older.” (April 13, 2009)
Age discrimination in hiring is hard to prove, but in a 2008 AARP survey, 60 percent of workers ages 45-74 said they had seen or experienced age bias. Even so, 70 percent in this age group plan to work past the traditional retirement age; nearly two thirds claimed financial need as the primary reason.
Even in this downturn, lack of significant interest by younger workers for certain job types, such as retail, health care and education makes some jobs somewhat more accessible to older workers.
More importantly, economic pressures are forcing employers to carefully evaluate their human resources, examine future needs and identify the best mix of people – both younger and older – to provide the greatest productivity and competitiveness.
Some employers still get caught up in ageist stereotypes, thinking all older workers don’t like change and won’t work hard, don’t understand new technologies, resent younger bosses and cost significantly more for health care. These are myths regarding most older employees, but sometimes apply to workers of any age.
Yet other employers recognize the significant benefits of 50 + workers: loyalty, strong work ethic, lower turnover and absenteeism rates, commitment to quality work and dependability in crises. Additionally, a 2005 Towers Perrin report found that older workers are highly motivated to exceed job expectations, which strongly correlates with job engagement and company performance.
All of this is important for older workers to keep in mind during these difficult times. Eventually, the crisis will pass, but America’s workforce will continue aging; a demographic shift set in motion long before the panic on Wall Street.
Therefore, for businesses that want to ensure long-term competitiveness in the 21st century, this will mean developing multi-generational work teams and designing policies and practices to attract and retain an increasingly age-diverse workforce.